This is one scoop!

One year, JD sauntered out of HOF with a cone piled high, saying "this in one scoop!" He wanted everyone to think he was suave enough to get the young ladies behind the counter to give him extra ice cream.

We later found out that he ordered two scoops, and did not receive special treatment. Since then, many attempts at claiming one giant scoop when two had been ordered have been made. Perhaps the most notable attempt was made in 2008 when Cory was caught red-handed in the oft-quoted lie:

"Cory: Hey guys - this is ONE scoop!

HOF girl: Ummm...no...you ordered a double.

Cory: No no - they like me here!"

Maybe next time, we'll try hitting up the Rinaldi's soft serve girls.